A legal tribunal has ruled that the Premier League’s sponsorship regulations from 2021 to 2024 are “void and unenforceable.” This decision comes after Manchester City challenged certain aspects of the league’s Associated Party Transaction (APT) regulations.
Tribunal’s Verdict on Sponsorship Regulations
An independent arbitration panel previously found issues in some APT rules. Despite this, the Premier League insists that the ruling does not affect the “valid operation” of its current APT regulations. The league maintains these rules are still “valid and enforceable” and continue in “full force.”
The APT rules were introduced to prevent clubs from inflating revenues through sponsorship deals with businesses linked to their owners. In November, despite opposition from Manchester City, Newcastle, Nottingham Forest, and Aston Villa, the Premier League voted to amend these regulations.
The tribunal’s latest ruling did not overturn these November changes but left them vulnerable to legal challenge. The panel concluded that three specific aspects of the APT rules were unlawful. Since these could not be separated from the rest of the rules, the tribunal deemed the entire set invalid.
Impact on the Premier League and Future Challenges
This ruling is a major blow to the Premier League. It suggests that clubs affected by these regulations before November 2024 might seek compensation. Some sources suggest that the league and its clubs could face financial liabilities amounting to tens of millions of pounds.
The decision has also put Premier League chief executive Richard Masters under scrutiny. He pushed for the amendments despite objections from Manchester City and Aston Villa.
The Premier League responded by stating that the ruling does not affect the validity of the new rules. It emphasized that the tribunal did not assess the effectiveness of the amended APT regulations, and a further legal battle will determine whether these new rules are lawful.
Background on APT Regulations
APT rules were first introduced in December 2021 following Newcastle United’s Saudi-led takeover. The league wanted to ensure that sponsorship agreements reflected fair market value and did not give certain clubs an unfair financial advantage. However, a tribunal ruling last year determined that low-interest shareholder loans should not be excluded from the APT scope. It also found that the strengthened regulations breached competition laws.
Manchester City has strongly criticized the Premier League for suggesting that the rules could be easily adjusted. The club argued that amendments should not be made until a final tribunal decision. Despite this, the league proceeded with changes in November. Earlier this month, City launched another legal challenge, arguing that the amended regulations remain unlawful.
Potential Consequences for the Premier League’s Leadership
The Premier League has already spent tens of millions of pounds on legal disputes related to financial rules. This ruling increases the likelihood of further legal challenges, with clubs possibly seeking compensation for undervalued or blocked sponsorship deals.
Manchester City sees this ruling as a validation of its stance, but the Premier League’s governance is now under increased pressure. If the arbitration panel rules that the amended regulations are also invalid, the league could face a serious crisis.
A decision against the Premier League could open the door for clubs like Abu Dhabi-backed Manchester City and Saudi-owned Newcastle United to secure lucrative sponsorship deals with state-linked sports companies. While this would benefit those clubs financially, critics argue it could threaten the league’s competitive balance.
Meanwhile, English football awaits another important legal ruling. The Premier League is still pursuing a separate disciplinary case against Manchester City, involving 115 charges of alleged financial rule breaches. The club denies any wrongdoing, but another ruling could significantly impact the league’s future.
For further updates, visit Euro News 24.